A DIFFERENT KIND OF BLUE

Occasionally it can be enlightening to cast a comparative glance towards local government in other countries, particularly countries who are also struggling with recession, austerity measures and varying degrees of commitment to localism.

From that vantage point, the report Putting People First’, published earlier this week by the Irish Government’s Department of the Environment, makes fascinating reading. 

The extent of cuts in local government funding in the UK have certainly resulted in a necessity to develop dramatically different ways of doing things. But the proposals put forward in ‘Putting People First’ make the changes on this side of the Irish Sea look like mere tinkering.

The report announces plans to consolidate local government by reducing the number of local councils to from 114 to 31 and cutting the number of elected councillors by 42%.

The local government context in Ireland differs markedly from the English experience. Irish local authorities have historically had a comparatively narrow range of functions, particularly with regard to social welfare, health, education, policing, transport and consumer protection. ‘Putting the People’ first does not propose to increase the scope of local influence over any of these policy areas.

The government has billed the proposals as “rebalancing of power to the democratically elected local councillor and away from the management system”, and  a way to achieve much needed civic engagement in the affairs of local government. But it is difficult to find anything in the report to back up these claims. There is scant evidence of delegation of powers to the local level; indeed the reverse is true. Alongside that, there seem to be little in consideration of alternative ways of engaging more effectively with citizens at the local level, given the removal of such a large number of local councillors and local structures. 

Initial reactions to the report have been perhaps surprisingly mixed. No-one doubts the dire financial situation Ireland finds itself in, and given the need to make significant savings, local government’s perceived bureaucracy has been a popular target, as has been the case in other countries. Furthermore, there has been widespread sentiment that a lack of transparency and accountability at the local level has fuelled corruption and inefficiency, and that local government needed to be ‘tackled’.

However, given the lack of concrete plans for how better civic engagement at the local level can be achieved, it is easy to also read in these proposals a worrying shift towards centralisation and a blow to the ability of Irish people to hold decision makers accountable and make local public services better.

AK

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. […] A DIFFERENT KIND OF BLUE by BDO local gov […]

  2. […] learn from that. This blog post highlights some of the proposed changes to local gov in Ireland in A DIFFERENT KIND OF BLUE Meanwhile back in England there are significant changes on the way for local gov as Phil Jewitt  […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

bdolocalgov

Thoughts, reflections and ruminations from the BDOlocalgov team. We don't always agree with each other. We'd love to hear what you think.

Jigsaw

Part of the Public Health Family

SEO Optimization Articles

SEO optimizaton atricles - your guide to the SEO world. Catch fresh and unique SEO content and use them in your SEO strategy

silkroadcollector.me

An International company that offers private antique art sales to clients around the globe.

Parenting And Stuff

Not a "how to be a great parent" blog

Government Digital Service

Putting the public first in delivering digital public services

ShropGrad

Welcome to Shropshire Council's Graduate blog!

Random thoughts from a human being

The only thing I've consistently said is that I'm inconsistent.

withavoiceofsinging

A blog about all things musical, and a little more besides...

sethsnap

Photographs from my world.

Bucket List Publications

Indulge- Travel, Adventure, & New Experiences

katemeout

Mainly eating and drinking my way through London. Sometimes spontaneously. Sometimes with a spreadsheet of options mapped to occasion, season, acquaintance and mood.

benthamtowers

A blog about work (#localgov), learning, family, friends, Shropshire, cake and things that are going on at Bentham Towers HQ.

Jon King

Musings from the world of public sector transformation - my views alone

social for the people

government social media training

Unsafe Spaces

Highlighting abuse and safeguarding issues in psychological therapies. Campaigning for stronger regulation in counselling and psychotherapy.

a day without OJ - A comms, digital & PR blog by Ross Wigham

"A day without orange juice is a helluva long day."

Stuart Mackintosh

Communications / PR / Marketing / Journalism / Family

%d bloggers like this: